The 50 Most Common Myths in Orthopaedics
Our evidence labels
We clearly distinguish between what studies demonstrate and what we know from clinical practice. This follows the three pillars of evidence-based medicine according to Sackett (BMJ 1996): the best available research evidence, clinical expertise and the patient's wishes.
- [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement
- [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
- [Our hypothesis] a physiologically plausible explanation that has yet to be scientifically tested
Diagnosis and MRI
Myth 1
Nothing shows up on the MRI – does that mean there is nothing wrong with me?
In brief: No. Many types of pain originate in muscles, fascia and tendons, and these causes often do not show up on MRI. If you are in pain, something is wrong – and we take that seriously.
The myth
“If nothing shows up on the MRI, there is nothing wrong with me.”
Many patients come to us with the words “There is nothing wrong with you” in their minds. The MRI was unremarkable, but the pain is still there. This is unsettling and often leads those affected to doubt themselves.
What the research says
A review in Current Pain and Headache Reports (2017) describes referred pain from muscles as the most common reason for back pain that radiates into the leg. The gluteus minimus muscle is even called the “pseudo-sciatica muscle” there, because it causes pain that is deceptively similar to that of a trapped nerve. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
An MRI mainly shows bones, intervertebral discs and nerves. Irritated muscles, adhesions in the fascia or a silently inflamed tendon often go unnoticed on it. With high-resolution ultrasound with elastography, however, such changes can often be detected. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- you have had cancer in the past,
- the pain began after a serious accident or fall,
- you have taken cortisone for a long time,
- paralysis, numbness in the genital area or problems passing urine occur – this is an emergency.
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 2: Herniated disc on MRI – is that the cause of my pain?
- Myth 4: Pain extending into the leg – does it always come from the disc?
- Myth 3: Pain gone – does that mean the herniated disc has healed?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Review of referred pain, Curr Pain Headache Rep 2017
Back to contentsMyth 2
Herniated disc on MRI – is that the cause of my pain?
In brief: Not necessarily. Disc bulges and wear and tear are also very common in people without any symptoms. A finding on an image is not automatically the cause of your pain.
The myth
“What shows up on the MRI is also causing my pain.”
If the MRI report says “herniated disc” or “osteoarthritis”, the situation seems clear. Many patients then focus all treatment on this finding – even if the pain is actually coming from somewhere else.
What the research says
Brinjikji and colleagues analysed 33 studies involving 3,110 people who had no back pain. Disc bulges were found in 30 % of 20-year-olds and 84 % of 80-year-olds. The authors emphasise that such findings must always be assessed in the context of the symptoms. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
A herniated disc can be visible on an image and still be “clinically silent”. The pain then comes from muscles or tendons, for example. What matters, therefore, is whether the findings and symptoms match. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- you have had cancer in the past,
- the pain began after a serious accident or fall,
- you have taken cortisone for a long time,
- paralysis, numbness in the genital area or problems passing urine occur – this is an emergency.
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 1: Nothing shows up on the MRI – does that mean there is nothing wrong with me?
- Myth 3: Pain gone – does that mean the herniated disc has healed?
- Myth 4: Pain extending into the leg – does it always come from the disc?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Brinjikji et al. 2015, AJNR
Back to contentsMyth 3
Pain gone – does that mean the herniated disc has healed?
In brief: Not always. Often, something else was treated, such as a tense muscle. The herniated disc may not have been the cause at all.
The myth
“If the treatment has helped, the herniated disc has healed.”
A patient has a herniated disc on MRI, receives physiotherapy, and the pain improves. The patient and therapist assume that the herniated disc has healed. If the symptoms return later and the same treatment suddenly no longer helps, they are very surprised.
What the research says
The review by Brinjikji and colleagues (2015) shows how frequently disc findings also occur without symptoms: a finding on an image is not automatically the cause of pain. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
In our experience, in such cases the pain often initially comes from the muscles, which were successfully treated. If the herniated disc does become active later, a new examination and a different treatment are needed. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- you have had cancer in the past,
- the pain began after a serious accident or fall,
- you have taken cortisone for a long time,
- paralysis, numbness in the genital area or problems passing urine occur – this is an emergency.
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 2: Herniated disc on MRI – is that the cause of my pain?
- Myth 4: Pain extending into the leg – does it always come from the disc?
- Myth 10: Is one method enough if you stick with it long enough?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Brinjikji et al. 2015, AJNR
Back to contentsMyth 4
Pain extending into the leg – does it always come from the disc?
In brief: No. Muscles and tendons can also trigger pain extending into the leg. This so-called pseudoradicular pain feels very similar to nerve pain.
The myth
“Pain extending into the leg always comes from the disc.”
When pain radiates into the leg, many people immediately think of a nerve trapped by a herniated disc. This sometimes leads to injections around the nerve or even surgery – although the cause lies somewhere else entirely.
What the research says
According to a review in Current Pain and Headache Reports (2017), referred pain from muscles is the most common reason for back pain radiating into the leg. The gluteus minimus muscle in particular can produce sciatica-like pain. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
Distinguishing true nerve pain (radicular) from muscle pain (pseudoradicular) is difficult but crucial. Often, both are involved. Both must then be treated. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- you have had cancer in the past,
- the pain began after a serious accident or fall,
- you have taken cortisone for a long time,
- paralysis, numbness in the genital area or problems passing urine occur – this is an emergency.
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 1: Nothing shows up on the MRI – does that mean there is nothing wrong with me?
- Myth 2: Herniated disc on MRI – is that the cause of my pain?
- Myth 10: Is one method enough if you stick with it long enough?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Review of referred pain, Curr Pain Headache Rep 2017
Back to contentsMyth 5
Is back pain always harmless?
In brief: Usually, yes. However, you should always have certain warning signs assessed by a doctor, because in rare cases there is something serious behind them.
The myth
“Back pain is always harmless.”
Back pain is very common, and usually there is nothing dangerous behind it. This makes it tempting to dismiss all symptoms – including the few for which a thorough assessment is important.
What the research says
Downie and colleagues (BMJ 2013) examined 53 warning signs from 14 studies. A previous history of cancer was the most informative indicator of a tumour; older age, long-term cortisone use and a serious accident were the most informative indicators of a vertebral fracture. [✓ Supported by research]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- you have had cancer in the past,
- the pain began after a serious accident or fall,
- you have taken cortisone for a long time,
- paralysis, numbness in the genital area or problems passing urine occur – this is an emergency.
- you are over 50 and the pain is new.
How we approach it
If there are warning signs, we first establish whether there is a serious cause before starting pain treatment. Only then do we begin the detailed search for the source of the pain.
Related myths
- Myth 1: Nothing shows up on the MRI – does that mean there is nothing wrong with me?
- Myth 2: Herniated disc on MRI – is that the cause of my pain?
- Myth 34: Does a painful back mainly need rest?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement
Sources: Downie et al. 2013, BMJ
Back to contentsTreatments and practitioners
Myth 6
Manipulation – was something really dislocated?
In brief: Usually not. Manipulation triggers a reflex that briefly reduces muscle tension – even if nothing was dislocated beforehand. The cause often remains.
The myth
“Manipulation addresses the cause because something was dislocated.”
Many patients undergo manipulation and are then pain-free for a few weeks. Then for a few days, then only for hours. They assume that something keeps becoming “dislocated”.
What the research says
Pickar (Spine Journal 2002) summarises that spinal manipulation triggers reflexes in the back muscles. Dishman and Bulbulian (Spine 2000) showed that the inhibition of the nerve cells that control the muscles was marked, but only temporary – after 30 seconds it had returned to baseline. [✓ Supported by research]
Our experience
This fits with our observation: the pain-free periods become shorter and shorter because the actual cause is not being treated. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 7: Does physiotherapy solve every back problem?
- Myth 10: Is one method enough if you stick with it long enough?
- Myth 11: Will it get better if I just keep going for treatment long enough?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Pickar 2002, Spine Journal · Dishman & Bulbulian 2000, Spine
Back to contentsMyth 7
Does physiotherapy solve every back problem?
In brief: No. Physiotherapy is valuable, but it does not treat every structure. If several tissues are involved, it is often not enough on its own.
The myth
“Physiotherapy solves every back problem.”
Physiotherapy is often the first step for back pain – rightly so. It becomes problematic when it continues for many months without any improvement because the actual cause has not been identified.
What the research says
The Cochrane review by Hayden and colleagues (2021), with 249 studies and 24,486 participants, shows that exercise therapy helps with chronic back pain. Compared with other conservative treatments, however, the benefit is small. [✓ Supported by research]
Our experience
The method is good, but it only treats part of the problem. If, for example, a nerve and a tendon are involved at the same time, a combination is needed. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 10: Is one method enough if you stick with it long enough?
- Myth 11: Will it get better if I just keep going for treatment long enough?
- Myth 27: Is strength training the best pain therapy?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Hayden et al. 2021, Cochrane
Back to contentsMyth 8
Is fascia always to blame?
In brief: No. Fascia can be involved in pain, but is usually not the only cause.
The myth
“Fascia is always to blame.”
In recent years, fascia has become a fashionable topic. Many patients believe that adhesions in the fascia are behind almost every pain – and that foam rollers or fascial therapy are the solution.
Our experience
In our experience, persistent pain usually involves several structures: muscles, tendons, fascia and sometimes a nerve as well. Fascial therapy does not help if the actual problem is the nerve or an inflamed tendon. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 7: Does physiotherapy solve every back problem?
- Myth 9: Can my osteopath resolve everything?
- Myth 10: Is one method enough if you stick with it long enough?
Key: [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Back to contentsMyth 9
Can my osteopath resolve everything?
In brief: Osteopathy can reduce muscle tension and relieve pain. Whether the effect lasts remains an open question, however – and not every cause can be treated with it.
The myth
“My osteopath can resolve everything.”
In Germany in particular, many patients have “their” osteopath whom they trust. That is understandable. It becomes difficult when symptoms keep returning and yet the actual cause is never investigated.
What the research says
Franke and colleagues (2014) evaluated 15 studies: osteopathy relieved non-specific back pain. However, measurements were only taken up to three months after treatment. The authors call for larger, high-quality studies. [✓ Supported by research]
Our experience
Acute back pain often improves on its own as well. An improvement therefore does not always mean that the cause has been resolved. In our experience, symptoms often return if the actual cause has not been found. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 10: Is one method enough if you stick with it long enough?
- Myth 12: My therapist is so convinced – does that mean it must be right?
- Myth 11: Will it get better if I just keep going for treatment long enough?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Franke et al. 2014, BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders · Costa et al. 2012, CMAJ
Back to contentsMyth 10
Is one method enough if you stick with it long enough?
In brief: Usually not. Acute back pain often improves on its own in the first few weeks. If the pain persists for longer, several structures are usually involved – and one method alone is then rarely enough.
The myth
“One method is enough if you just stick with it long enough.”
Whether manipulation, massage or an injection: almost every treatment appears successful at first. This encourages many people to stick with a single method, even if the symptoms return later.
What the research says
Costa and colleagues (CMAJ 2012) showed in a meta-analysis: patients with acute and persistent back pain improve considerably in the first six weeks, after which improvement slows. After a year, patients with persistent pain in particular still had mild to moderate symptoms. [✓ Supported by research]
Our experience
The early improvement is therefore often the natural course, not the success of a particular method. In our experience, what remains afterwards usually has several causes at the same time. Manipulation does not help an irritated tendon, and fascial therapy does not help a trapped nerve. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 11: Will it get better if I just keep going for treatment long enough?
- Myth 7: Does physiotherapy solve every back problem?
- Myth 9: Can my osteopath resolve everything?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Costa et al. 2012, CMAJ
Back to contentsMyth 11
Will it get better if I just keep going to therapy long enough?
In brief: Not necessarily. After three to six treatments, you should notice a tangible improvement. If not, it is time to have the diagnosis reviewed.
The myth
“If I keep going to therapy long enough, it will get better.”
Some patients go to therapy for months without anything changing. They hope that success will come eventually. In the process, they lose valuable time.
What the research says
Cook and colleagues (2017) showed: those who had a third less pain after two weeks of treatment were five to seven times more likely to have a good outcome after six months. Another study (Pain Practice 2006) was able to correctly predict around 80% of treatment outcomes from progress during sessions two to four. [✓ Supported by research]
Our experience
Our rule of thumb, wherever you are treated: after three to six treatments, there should be a tangible improvement. After six treatments, it is best to take a break and see whether the effect lasts. If not, have the diagnosis reviewed. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
Before starting, we discuss how many treatments are likely to be needed and regularly assess their success. If there is no improvement, we review the diagnosis rather than simply carrying on.
Related myths
- Myth 14: The more treatments, the better?
- Myth 13: If a therapy has not helped – does that mean nothing else will help?
- Myth 12: My therapist is so convinced – does that mean it must be right?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Cook et al. 2017, Physiother Theory Pract · Early improvement in physiotherapy, Pain Practice 2006
Back to contentsMyth 12
My therapist is so convinced – does that mean it must be right?
In brief: Conviction is no substitute for a diagnosis. What matters is whether you feel better in the long term.
The myth
“My therapist is so convinced, so it must be right.”
Many practitioners come across as very convincing, and patients trust them. That is a good thing in principle. But whether a treatment is the right one is shown not by conviction, but by progress.
Our experience
In our experience, some patients stick with a treatment for a long time because the therapist seems very sure – even though nothing improves. Pay attention to your own progress: is there a tangible improvement after a few treatments? Does the improvement last? [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We explain to you what we have found and why we suggest a particular treatment. We assess its success together with you.
Related myths
- Myth 11: Will it get better if I just keep going for treatment long enough?
- Myth 13: If a therapy has not helped – does that mean nothing else will help?
- Myth 14: The more treatments, the better?
Key: [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Back to contentsMyth 13
If a therapy has not helped – does that mean nothing else will help?
In brief: No, it does not. If a treatment has not helped, it was often simply not suited to the cause. With the right diagnosis, there is often another way.
The myth
“If a therapy has not helped, nothing else will help.”
After many unsuccessful treatments, some patients lose hope. They believe they have to live with the pain.
Our experience
In our experience, it is usually not because “nothing helps”, but because the treatment was not suited to the cause. A targeted search often finds a structure that has previously been overlooked. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 10: Is one method enough if you stick with it long enough?
- Myth 11: Will it get better if I just keep going for treatment long enough?
- Myth 1: Nothing shows up on the MRI – does that mean there is nothing wrong with me?
Key: [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Back to contentsMyth 14
The more treatments, the better?
In brief: No. If nothing improves after a few treatments, further sessions of the same kind rarely achieve much.
The myth
“The more treatments, the better.”
More helps more – that sounds logical. But it is not true of pain treatments. Anyone who keeps going without improvement loses time, money and motivation.
Our experience
In our experience, it becomes clear early on whether a treatment is suitable. This is consistent with studies showing that early improvement predicts a good outcome (see Myth 11). [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We plan the number of treatments in advance and take breaks to check whether the effect lasts.
Related myths
- Myth 11: Will it get better if I just keep going for treatment long enough?
- Myth 12: My therapist is so convinced – does that mean it must be right?
- Myth 13: If a therapy has not helped – does that mean nothing else will help?
Key: [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Cook et al. 2017, Physiother Theory Pract
Back to contentsInjections and medication
Myth 15
Does a cortisone injection cure the problem?
In brief: No. Cortisone can reduce pain and inflammation in the short term, but it does not change the cause. Repeated injections into the joint can even damage the cartilage.
The myth
“A cortisone injection cures the problem.”
For many patients, a quick injection is the epitome of orthopaedic treatment. It often works rapidly, creating the impression that the problem has been resolved.
What the research says
McAlindon and colleagues (JAMA 2017) gave 140 patients with knee osteoarthritis injections of cortisone or saline into the joint every three months over two years. More cartilage was lost with cortisone (–0.21 mm versus –0.10 mm), and pain relief was no greater than with saline. [✓ Supported by research]
How we approach it
Cortisone is not a standard solution for us. We first look for the cause and treat it in a targeted way. Where an injection is appropriate, we use it deliberately and with justification.
Related myths
- Myth 16: Do painkillers solve the problem?
- Myth 17: Do strong painkillers such as opioids work best for chronic pain?
- Myth 19: Can osteoarthritis be cured?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement
Sources: McAlindon et al. 2017, JAMA
Back to contentsMyth 16
Do painkillers solve the problem?
In brief: No. Painkillers dampen the pain; they do nothing to change the cause. In studies, paracetamol is in fact no better than a placebo for back pain.
The myth
“Painkillers solve the problem.”
Many people take tablets for back or joint pain over a long period. The pain becomes quieter, but the cause remains – and is sometimes only recognised late.
What the research says
Machado and colleagues (BMJ 2015) analysed 13 studies involving over 5,300 patients. Paracetamol was no better than a placebo for back pain and had only a minimal effect on osteoarthritis. [✓ Supported by research]
How we approach it
We look for the cause of your pain and treat it specifically, so that you need as few painkillers as possible.
Related myths
- Myth 17: Do strong painkillers such as opioids work best for chronic pain?
- Myth 15: Does a cortisone injection cure the problem?
- Myth 10: Is one method enough if you stick with it long enough?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement
Sources: Machado et al. 2015, BMJ
Back to contentsMyth 17
Do strong painkillers such as opioids work best for chronic pain?
In brief: No. For chronic back, hip or knee problems, opioids are no better than simple painkillers in the long term, but have more side effects.
The myth
“Strong painkillers such as opioids work best for chronic back and joint pain.”
When simple painkillers are no longer enough, the next step seems clear: a stronger medication. Many patients assume that a stronger medication also works better.
What the research says
Krebs and colleagues (JAMA 2018, SPACE study) treated 240 patients with moderate to severe chronic back pain or hip and knee osteoarthritis for twelve months with either opioids or non-opioids. There was no difference in everyday functioning. Pain intensity was actually slightly lower in the group without opioids, and side effects occurred more frequently with opioids. [✓ Supported by research]
Our experience
A stronger medication dampens the pain but does nothing to change its cause. That is why we first look for where the pain is coming from. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We look for the cause of your pain and treat it specifically, so that you need as few painkillers as possible. We use medication deliberately and for a limited time.
Related myths
- Myth 16: Do painkillers solve the problem?
- Myth 15: Does a cortisone injection cure the problem?
- Myth 10: Is one method enough if you stick with it long enough?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Krebs et al. 2018, JAMA (SPACE)
Back to contentsMyth 18
Does a plasma injection help with every case of knee pain?
In brief: No. Not all knee pain in osteoarthritis comes from the joint. Before an injection is given into the joint, it must be clear where the pain is coming from.
The myth
“A plasma injection helps with every case of knee pain.”
People with knee pain and osteoarthritis on an X-ray are often given an injection straight into the joint – without checking whether the pain really comes from there.
What the research says
In the RESTORE study (Bennell and colleagues, JAMA 2021), plasma was no better than a placebo for patients with knee pain and osteoarthritis on an X-ray. Where the pain came from was not checked beforehand. [✓ Supported by research]
Our experience
Muscles or tendons around the knee are often involved. And if the knee is currently swollen, in our experience the inflammation must subside first. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- the knee swells or becomes warm,
- the knee locks or gives way,
- the pain does not ease despite rest.
How we approach it
We examine the joint, muscles and tendons together, using high-resolution ultrasound and elastography, among other methods. Only once it is clear where the pain is coming from do we decide on the treatment.
Related myths
- Myth 21: Keep doing sport with osteoarthritis – no matter what?
- Myth 23: The worse the osteoarthritis on the X-ray, the worse the pain?
- Myth 15: Does a cortisone injection cure the problem?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Bennell et al. 2021, JAMA (RESTORE)
Back to contentsOsteoarthritis and joints
Myth 19
Can osteoarthritis be cured?
In brief: No. Osteoarthritis cannot be cured. However, the pain can be treated and its progression slowed as much as possible.
The myth
“Osteoarthritis can be cured.”
Many treatments promise to “reverse” osteoarthritis or rebuild cartilage. This leads to disappointment and sometimes to expensive treatments with no benefit.
What the research says
There is medical consensus that osteoarthritis cannot be cured. In keeping with this, neither cortisone (McAlindon 2017) nor plasma (Bennell 2021) built up cartilage in studies. [✓ Supported by research]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- the knee swells or becomes warm,
- the knee locks or gives way,
- the pain does not ease despite rest.
How we approach it
We distinguish between the acute pain phase and the pain-free period. During the pain phase, we treat the inflammation; afterwards, the aim is to keep the joint mobile and able to bear load.
Related myths
- Myth 20: Should you rest the joint if you have osteoarthritis?
- Myth 21: Keep doing sport with osteoarthritis – no matter what?
- Myth 15: Does a cortisone injection cure the problem?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement
Sources: McAlindon et al. 2017, JAMA · Bennell et al. 2021, JAMA (RESTORE)
Back to contentsMyth 20
Should you rest the joint if you have osteoarthritis?
In brief: No – but you should not put it under heavy strain either. The joint needs free movement without resistance, for example cycling on level ground.
The myth
“If you have osteoarthritis, you should rest the joint.”
For fear of pain, many people with osteoarthritis barely move their joint any more. Others train with heavy weights because they have heard that muscles protect the joint.
Causes and triggers
Movement is not the same as loading. The joint benefits from free movement through its full remaining range, without much resistance. Cycling on level ground with little effort is ideal; cycling uphill or training with a lot of resistance, on the other hand, is not. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- the knee swells or becomes warm,
- the knee locks or gives way,
- the pain does not ease despite rest.
How we approach it
We examine the joint, muscles and tendons together, using high-resolution ultrasound and elastography, among other methods. Only once it is clear where the pain is coming from do we decide on the treatment.
Related myths
- Myth 21: Keep doing sport with osteoarthritis – no matter what?
- Myth 22: Does strength training always help with osteoarthritis?
- Myth 19: Can osteoarthritis be cured?
Key: [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Back to contentsMyth 21
Keep doing sport with osteoarthritis – no matter what?
In brief: Movement is usually good. But if the joint swells, the osteoarthritis is active. This is one of the few situations in which we advise temporarily reducing sport.
The myth
“If I have osteoarthritis, I must keep doing sport, no matter what.”
“Movement is the best remedy for osteoarthritis” – this statement is usually true. However, many take it to mean that you should simply keep training even with a swollen, inflamed knee.
What the research says
Hill and colleagues (Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases 2007) followed 270 patients with knee osteoarthritis. When inflammation of the joint lining increased, pain also increased. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
That is why, when osteoarthritis is active, the inflammation must subside first before the load is increased again. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- the knee swells or becomes warm,
- the knee locks or gives way,
- the pain does not ease despite rest.
How we approach it
We examine the joint, muscles and tendons together, using high-resolution ultrasound and elastography, among other methods. Only once it is clear where the pain is coming from do we decide on the treatment.
Related myths
- Myth 20: Should you rest the joint if you have osteoarthritis?
- Myth 22: Does strength training always help with osteoarthritis?
- Myth 18: Does a plasma injection help with every case of knee pain?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Hill et al. 2007, Ann Rheum Dis
Back to contentsMyth 22
Does strength training always help with osteoarthritis?
In brief: Training generally helps with osteoarthritis. But if the joint is currently swollen and inflamed, the inflammation should subside first.
The myth
“Strength training always helps with osteoarthritis, even if the knee is currently swollen.”
Strength training is often recommended across the board for osteoarthritis. In our experience, however, training with an active, swollen joint often makes symptoms worse.
Causes and triggers
The guidelines explicitly recommend training for knee osteoarthritis, and we support this. In our experience, however, patients come to us with active osteoarthritis after doing strength training despite swelling. This is consistent with the finding that more inflammation in the joint also means more pain (Hill 2007, see Myth 21). [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- the knee swells or becomes warm,
- the knee locks or gives way,
- the pain does not ease despite rest.
How we approach it
We examine the joint, muscles and tendons together, using high-resolution ultrasound and elastography, among other methods. Only once it is clear where the pain is coming from do we decide on the treatment.
Related myths
- Myth 21: Keep doing sport with osteoarthritis – no matter what?
- Myth 20: Should you rest the joint if you have osteoarthritis?
- Myth 27: Is strength training the best pain therapy?
Key: [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Hill et al. 2007, Ann Rheum Dis
Back to contentsMyth 23
The worse the osteoarthritis on the X-ray, the worse the pain?
In brief: No. The extent of osteoarthritis on the image and the severity of the pain are often only loosely related.
The myth
“The worse the osteoarthritis on the X-ray, the worse the pain.”
Many patients are alarmed by their X-ray and expect the pain to inevitably get worse. Others wonder why they have severe pain despite “mild” osteoarthritis.
What the research says
Bedson and Croft (BMC 2008) summarised the literature: depending on the study, only 15 to 81% of people with osteoarthritis on an X-ray had knee pain. The X-ray alone should therefore not be used to assess knee pain. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
Often the pain does not come from the cartilage, but from irritated tendons, muscles or inflammation in the joint. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- the knee swells or becomes warm,
- the knee locks or gives way,
- the pain does not ease despite rest.
How we approach it
We examine the joint, muscles and tendons together, using high-resolution ultrasound and elastography, among other methods. Only once it is clear where the pain is coming from do we decide on the treatment.
Related myths
- Myth 24: The knee cracks – is that osteoarthritis?
- Myth 2: Herniated disc on MRI – is that the cause of my pain?
- Myth 18: Does a plasma injection help with every case of knee pain?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Bedson & Croft 2008, BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders
Back to contentsMyth 24
My knee cracks – is it osteoarthritis?
In brief: No, a cracking knee does not automatically mean osteoarthritis. But it is a reason to take a closer look.
The myth
“If your knee cracks, it is osteoarthritis.”
Many people are alarmed when their knee cracks while climbing stairs or squatting. Their first thought: “Now the cartilage is damaged.” That is not necessarily true.
What the research says
A large study with several thousand participants shows: people who frequently notice cracking in their knee have a slightly higher risk of developing painful osteoarthritis later on, especially if initial changes are already visible on an X-ray (Lo and colleagues, Arthritis Care & Research 2018). [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
The cracking becomes audible, for example, through small gas bubbles in the joint – but this is only what triggers the sound. In our experience, the actual cause often lies in excessive muscle tension around the knee [Clinical experience]. Our hypothesis: if the resting tension is too high, the kneecap is pressed more firmly against the joint, which can promote osteoarthritis behind the kneecap over time [Our hypothesis]. In our practice, we regularly see the cracking disappear when the muscle tension is treated. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- pain occurs with the cracking,
- the knee swells or becomes warm,
- the knee locks or gives way.
How we approach it
We examine not only the joint but also the muscles and tendons around the knee, using high-resolution ultrasound among other methods. This allows us to find out where the cracking really comes from and specifically treat the cause.
Related myths
- Myth 23: The worse the osteoarthritis on the X-ray, the worse the pain?
- Myth 28: Does running damage your knees?
- Myth 20: Should you rest the joint if you have osteoarthritis?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet · [Our hypothesis] a physiologically plausible explanation that has yet to be scientifically tested
Sources: Lo et al. 2018, Arthritis Care & Research
Back to contentsSport and running
Myth 25
Must I stop doing sport if I am in pain?
In brief: Usually not. Our principle is: never take an athlete out of sport completely. A complete break rarely solves the problem.
The myth
“If I am in pain, I must stop doing sport.”
Many athletes who experience pain during activity are advised to take a longer break. After the break, the symptoms often return, sometimes even in new places.
What the research says
Silbernagel and colleagues (Am J Sports Med 2007) studied 38 patients with Achilles tendon problems. Those who continued running and jumping during treatment did no worse than the group who took a six-week break. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
In our experience, pain during activity is often caused by silent inflammation in the tendon [Clinical experience]. A break allows the pain to subside, but the inflammation remains. [Our hypothesis]
How we approach it
We use high-resolution ultrasound, elastography and our Silent Inflammation Check-up to examine whether silent inflammation is behind it. You continue training with adjustments and return to full performance step by step with our Back-to-Sport concept and the One-Quarter Method.
Related myths
- Myth 26: Running less – does that solve the problem?
- Myth 32: No pain, no progress?
- Myth 50: Once the pain is gone, is the cause gone too?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet · [Our hypothesis] a physiologically plausible explanation that has yet to be scientifically tested
Sources: Silbernagel et al. 2007, Am J Sports Med
Back to contentsMyth 26
Running less – does that solve the problem?
In brief: No. Running less dampens the pain but does not address the cause. Our aim is for you to be able to run the way you want to again.
The myth
“If I run less, the problem is solved.”
Does this sound familiar? Everything is fine in everyday life. But from 25 kilometres onwards, your knee starts playing up. And the advice is: “Then just run less.”
What the research says
In the study by Silbernagel and colleagues (2007), a break from sport was not necessary: patients who continued training with adjustments achieved the same results. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
In our experience, this kind of pain during activity is often caused by silent inflammation, a Silent Inflammation [Clinical experience]. Our hypothesis: if the tendon is silently inflamed, the control of the muscles via the tension receptors in the tendon falls out of sync, and the risk of injury increases. [Our hypothesis]
How we approach it
We use high-resolution ultrasound, elastography and our Silent Inflammation Check-up to examine whether silent inflammation is behind it. You continue training with adjustments and return to full performance step by step with our Back-to-Sport concept and the One-Quarter Method.
Related myths
- Myth 25: Must I stop doing sport if I am in pain?
- Myth 28: Does running damage your knees?
- Myth 50: Once the pain is gone, is the cause gone too?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet · [Our hypothesis] a physiologically plausible explanation that has yet to be scientifically tested
Sources: Silbernagel et al. 2007, Am J Sports Med
Back to contentsMyth 27
Is strength training the best pain therapy?
In brief: No. Strength training is training, not pain therapy. It is valuable, but it does not replace the search for the cause.
The myth
“Strength training is the best pain therapy.”
Strength training is now recommended for almost every kind of pain. Many people train for months to keep their symptoms in check – and as soon as they stop, the symptoms return.
What the research says
The Cochrane review by Hayden and colleagues (2021) shows: exercise relieves chronic back pain, but only slightly compared with other treatments. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
According to our strength measurements in practice, muscular imbalances are only rarely the actual cause. If training merely keeps the pain in check, it returns as soon as you stop. The principle is therefore: first find and treat the cause, then sport becomes enjoyable again too. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 49: Is back pain caused by weak abdominal muscles?
- Myth 22: Does strength training always help with osteoarthritis?
- Myth 7: Does physiotherapy solve every back problem?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Hayden et al. 2021, Cochrane
Back to contentsMyth 28
Does running damage your knees?
In brief: No. Running is not a problem for healthy joints. Recreational runners are even less likely to have osteoarthritis than people who do not run at all.
The myth
“Running damages your knees.”
“You will damage your knees with all that running” – many runners hear this sentence. It persists stubbornly, even though the research paints a different picture.
What the research says
Alentorn-Geli and colleagues (JOSPT 2017) analysed 17 studies involving 114,829 people. Hip or knee osteoarthritis was present in 3.5 % of recreational runners, 10.2 % of non-runners and 13.3 % of competitive runners. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
In our experience, difficulties only arise when someone runs for years with a misalignment, such as unfavourable leg alignment, or continues running with untreated tendon inflammation. So running is not the problem – it is what remains undetected while running. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- the knee swells or becomes warm,
- the knee locks or gives way,
- the pain does not ease despite rest.
How we approach it
We use high-resolution ultrasound, elastography and our Silent Inflammation Check-up to examine whether silent inflammation is behind it. You continue training with adjustments and return to full performance step by step with our Back-to-Sport concept and the One-Quarter Method.
Related myths
- Myth 29: Does running on tarmac harm your joints?
- Myth 33: Should you stop running in old age?
- Myth 24: The knee cracks – is that osteoarthritis?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Alentorn-Geli et al. 2017, JOSPT
Back to contentsMyth 29
Does running on tarmac harm your joints?
In brief: No. The body adapts to the surface. On hard ground, the leg automatically works more softly; on soft ground, more stiffly.
The myth
“Running on tarmac harms your joints.”
Many runners avoid tarmac because they believe the hard ground harms their joints. However, good footwear and an appropriate training load are more important than the surface.
What the research says
Ferris and colleagues (1998 and 1999) showed that runners adapt their leg stiffness to the surface. When switching from soft to hard ground, leg stiffness decreased by 29 % on the very first step, so that the movement pattern remained the same. [✓ Supported by research]
How we approach it
We use high-resolution ultrasound, elastography and our Silent Inflammation Check-up to examine whether silent inflammation is behind it. You continue training with adjustments and return to full performance step by step with our Back-to-Sport concept and the One-Quarter Method.
Related myths
- Myth 30: Is running in the woods or on sand gentler?
- Myth 28: Does running damage your knees?
- Myth 33: Should you stop running in old age?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement
Sources: Ferris et al. 1998, Proc R Soc B · Ferris et al. 1999, J Biomech
Back to contentsMyth 30
Is running in the woods or on sand gentler?
In brief: Not necessarily. On uneven ground, the muscles constantly have to readjust. Particularly when there are symptoms or irritated tendons, this can actually cause additional problems.
The myth
“Running in the woods or on sand is gentler on the joints.”
Soft woodland ground or sand are considered particularly gentle on the joints. What is overlooked is that on uneven ground, the next step is never entirely certain.
What the research says
Voloshina and colleagues (J Exp Biol 2013) showed: on uneven ground, seven muscles in the lower leg and thigh worked harder, and the knee and hip performed 28 and 62 % more work respectively. The measurements were taken in healthy people. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
The muscles constantly have to readjust to stabilise the foot and knee. In our experience, this constant fine-tuning can trigger additional problems in people with symptoms. In healthy people, by contrast, uneven ground can specifically train coordination. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We use high-resolution ultrasound, elastography and our Silent Inflammation Check-up to examine whether silent inflammation is behind it. You continue training with adjustments and return to full performance step by step with our Back-to-Sport concept and the One-Quarter Method.
Related myths
- Myth 29: Does running on tarmac harm your joints?
- Myth 28: Does running damage your knees?
- Myth 47: Is a heel spur to blame for my heel pain?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Voloshina et al. 2013, J Exp Biol
Back to contentsMyth 31
Does stretching protect against injuries?
In brief: No. Stretching alone does not reduce the risk of injury. Strength training, on the other hand, does.
The myth
“Stretching protects against injuries.”
For many people, stretching thoroughly before sport is an essential part of the routine. The hope is that this will keep injuries at bay.
What the research says
Lauersen and colleagues (BJSM 2014) evaluated 25 studies involving 26,610 participants. Stretching did not reduce the risk of injury; strength training reduced it to less than a third. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
In our experience, injuries usually arise for other reasons: through silent inflammation, misalignments or increasing the load too quickly [Clinical experience]. Those who want to keep their muscles supple tend to stretch briefly. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We use high-resolution ultrasound, elastography and our Silent Inflammation Check-up to examine whether silent inflammation is behind it. You continue training with adjustments and return to full performance step by step with our Back-to-Sport concept and the One-Quarter Method.
Related myths
- Myth 32: No pain, no progress?
- Myth 25: Must I stop doing sport if I am in pain?
- Myth 50: Once the pain is gone, is the cause gone too?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Lauersen et al. 2014, BJSM
Back to contentsMyth 32
No pain, no progress?
In brief: No. Pain is not a prerequisite for progress. Mild pain during training is acceptable, but is not necessary, and it should subside by the next morning.
The myth
“No pain, no progress.”
“No pain, no gain” – the saying from the gym persists stubbornly. Some people therefore deliberately train through pain, overloading their tendons in the process.
What the research says
Smith and colleagues (BJSM 2017) found no difference in the medium and long term between exercises with and without pain. In the study by Silbernagel and colleagues (2007), pain up to 5 out of 10 was allowed, but it had to have subsided by the next morning. [✓ Supported by research]
How we approach it
We use high-resolution ultrasound, elastography and our Silent Inflammation Check-up to examine whether silent inflammation is behind it. You continue training with adjustments and return to full performance step by step with our Back-to-Sport concept and the One-Quarter Method.
Related myths
- Myth 25: Must I stop doing sport if I am in pain?
- Myth 31: Does stretching protect against injuries?
- Myth 26: Running less – does that solve the problem?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement
Sources: Smith et al. 2017, BJSM · Silbernagel et al. 2007, Am J Sports Med
Back to contentsMyth 33
Should you stop running in old age?
In brief: No. Running is healthy in old age too. Our aim is for you to be able to practise your sport into advanced old age.
The myth
“At my age, you should no longer run.”
“At your age, you should no longer run” – many older runners hear this from friends, family or even doctors.
What the research says
Chakravarty and colleagues followed 284 runners aged over 50 for 21 years (Arch Intern Med 2008). The runners had fewer disabilities and lived longer. In a second study (Am J Prev Med 2008), long-distance running did not accelerate knee osteoarthritis in older people. [✓ Supported by research]
How we approach it
We use high-resolution ultrasound, elastography and our Silent Inflammation Check-up to examine whether silent inflammation is behind it. You continue training with adjustments and return to full performance step by step with our Back-to-Sport concept and the One-Quarter Method.
Related myths
- Myth 28: Does running damage your knees?
- Myth 29: Does running on tarmac harm your joints?
- Myth 25: Must I stop doing sport if I am in pain?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement
Sources: Chakravarty et al. 2008, Arch Intern Med · Chakravarty et al. 2008, Am J Prev Med
Back to contentsBack pain and everyday life
Myth 34
Does an aching back need rest above all?
In brief: No. Staying active helps more than bed rest. An antalgic posture can even make the symptoms worse.
The myth
“An aching back needs rest above all.”
In the past, the advice for back pain was: off to bed. Even today, many people take it easy for fear of damaging something.
What the research says
The Cochrane review by Dahm and colleagues (2010) shows that, for acute back pain, advice to stay active provides slightly more pain relief and better function than bed rest. [✓ Supported by research]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- you have had cancer in the past,
- the pain began after a serious accident or fall,
- you have taken cortisone for a long time,
- paralysis, numbness in the genital area or problems passing urine occur – this is an emergency.
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 36: Does heavy lifting ruin your back?
- Myth 37: Does sitting upright protect against back pain?
- Myth 5: Is back pain always harmless?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement
Sources: Dahm et al. 2010, Cochrane
Back to contentsMyth 35
Is the cold to blame for my back pain?
In brief: No. The weather is not the cause of back pain. People who develop symptoms in winter usually already have a problem, for example in their muscles.
The myth
“The cold is to blame for my back pain.”
Many people attribute their back pain to cold, draughts or changes in the weather and rely mainly on warmth.
What the research says
Steffens and colleagues (Arthritis Care & Research 2014) studied 993 patients. Temperature, humidity, air pressure and rain did not increase the risk of a new episode of back pain. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
It is therefore worth looking for the actual cause rather than relying solely on warmth. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- you have had cancer in the past,
- the pain began after a serious accident or fall,
- you have taken cortisone for a long time,
- paralysis, numbness in the genital area or problems passing urine occur – this is an emergency.
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 36: Does heavy lifting ruin your back?
- Myth 34: Does a painful back mainly need rest?
- Myth 37: Does sitting upright protect against back pain?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Steffens et al. 2014, Arthritis Care & Research
Back to contentsMyth 36
Does heavy lifting ruin your back?
In brief: No. Heavy lifting is usually only the trigger, for example for lumbago. The actual cause is often already there.
The myth
“Heavy lifting ruins your back.”
After an episode of lumbago while lifting, people usually blame the load. Many then stop lifting anything heavy altogether.
What the research says
Wai and colleagues (Spine Journal 2010) evaluated 35 studies. Occupational lifting alone is unlikely to cause back pain. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
We distinguish between the cause and the trigger. The cause often lies in poor posture, muscular imbalances or impaired coordination [Clinical experience]. Our hypothesis: if the tension receptors in the tendons are irritated, they set the resting tension of the muscles incorrectly, and a perfectly normal load suddenly becomes too much. [Our hypothesis]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- you have had cancer in the past,
- the pain began after a serious accident or fall,
- you have taken cortisone for a long time,
- paralysis, numbness in the genital area or problems passing urine occur – this is an emergency.
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 34: Does a painful back mainly need rest?
- Myth 35: Is the cold to blame for my back pain?
- Myth 37: Does sitting upright protect against back pain?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet · [Our hypothesis] a physiologically plausible explanation that has yet to be scientifically tested
Sources: Wai et al. 2010, Spine Journal
Back to contentsMyth 37
Does sitting upright protect against back pain?
In brief: No. Sitting upright is a forced posture. Sitting freely and in a relaxed way, keeping the buttock muscles relaxed, is better.
The myth
“Always sit nice and upright, then I won't get back pain.”
“Sit up straight!” – most people know this phrase from childhood. Many still force themselves into an upright posture in the hope of protecting their back.
What the research says
Swain and colleagues (J Biomech 2020) evaluated 41 reviews. There is no consensus that particular postures or sitting cause back pain. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
In our experience, forced postures tend to cause more symptoms. Sitting incorrectly is more of a trigger than the actual cause. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 38: Is an orthopaedic sports seat in the car gentle on your back?
- Myth 39: Does a lumbar support protect your back?
- Myth 36: Does heavy lifting ruin your back?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Swain et al. 2020, J Biomech
Back to contentsMyth 38
Is an orthopaedic sports seat in the car gentle on your back?
In brief: Not necessarily. Many sports seats press against the sides of the buttock muscles. It is more important that the muscles are not constricted when sitting.
The myth
“An orthopaedic sports seat in the car is gentle on my back.”
A sports seat with pronounced side bolsters appears stable and healthy. On longer journeys, however, this is precisely when many drivers develop symptoms in their buttocks or back.
Causes and triggers
In our experience and according to feedback from our patients, pressure on the sides of the buttock muscles can trigger symptoms, similar to wallet syndrome, when someone constantly sits with their wallet in their back pocket [Clinical experience]. Our tip: place a small cushion on the seat. It compensates for the raised sides so that the buttocks rest freely on the seat. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 39: Does a lumbar support protect your back?
- Myth 37: Does sitting upright protect against back pain?
- Myth 4: Pain extending into the leg – does it always come from the disc?
Key: [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Back to contentsMyth 39
Does a lumbar support protect your back?
In brief: In our experience, it offers little benefit to most patients. Sitting freely and in a relaxed way is more important.
The myth
“A lumbar support protects my back.”
Lumbar supports are built into many car seats and office chairs and are considered back-friendly.
Causes and triggers
A lumbar support pushes the back into a particular shape – and that is another forced posture. This statement is based on our experience and feedback from our patients. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 37: Does sitting upright protect against back pain?
- Myth 38: Is an orthopaedic sports seat in the car gentle on your back?
- Myth 40: The firmer the mattress, the better for your back?
Key: [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Back to contentsMyth 40
The firmer the mattress, the better for your back?
In brief: No. A firm mattress is not automatically good for your back. And no mattress treats the actual cause of back pain.
The myth
“The harder the mattress, the better for your back.”
For a long time, the rule was: anyone with back pain needs a particularly hard mattress. Many invest a lot of money in expensive mattresses and hope for a solution.
What the research says
Kovacs and colleagues (Lancet 2003) gave 313 patients with chronic back pain a firm or a medium-firm mattress. Pain and limitation improved more with the medium-firm mattress. [✓ Supported by research]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 41: Does a special pillow ensure better sleep?
- Myth 37: Does sitting upright protect against back pain?
- Myth 34: Does a painful back mainly need rest?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement
Sources: Kovacs et al. 2003, Lancet
Back to contentsMyth 41
Does a special pillow ensure better sleep?
In brief: Not necessarily. A pillow is primarily an aid to falling asleep. No pillow solves a disc problem.
The myth
“A special pillow ensures better sleep.”
Numerous special pillows are offered for neck pain and poor sleep. Many people try one after another.
What the research says
Pang and colleagues (Clin Biomech 2021) evaluated 35 studies. The type of pillow had no influence on sleep quality. Latex pillows reduced neck pain only slightly. Shape and height mattered for the posture of the cervical spine. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
Most people change position several times during the night. The shape and height of the pillow therefore only matter if you are still lying in the morning as you were when you fell asleep. Otherwise, the pillow should above all be comfortable. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 40: The firmer the mattress, the better for your back?
- Myth 37: Does sitting upright protect against back pain?
- Myth 1: Nothing shows up on the MRI – does that mean there is nothing wrong with me?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Pang et al. 2021, Clin Biomech
Back to contentsSurgery
Myth 42
Does it need surgery – is there no other solution?
In brief: Not always. Even with a herniated disc with sciatica, the outcome after one year with conservative treatment is often just as good as with surgery.
The myth
“If the doctor says this needs surgery, there is no other solution.”
Many patients come to us with the sentence in their minds: “This needs surgery.” That can feel as though there is no other solution.
What the research says
Peul and colleagues (NEJM 2007) compared early surgery with longer conservative treatment in 283 patients with sciatica. After one year, the outcomes were the same; 95 % in both groups felt recovered. Improvement was faster with surgery. 61 % of conservatively treated patients never needed surgery. [✓ Supported by research]
Our experience
We are not against operations. If an operation is really necessary, it is the right decision. What matters is that the right person is operated on. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- you have had cancer in the past,
- the pain began after a serious accident or fall,
- you have taken cortisone for a long time,
- paralysis, numbness in the genital area or problems passing urine occur – this is an emergency.
How we approach it
We take time to provide a thorough second opinion. We check whether the symptoms really come from the findings and discuss openly when an operation makes sense and when it does not.
Related myths
- Myth 43: Is the pain guaranteed to be gone after the operation?
- Myth 44: The earlier the operation, the better?
- Myth 46: Is the problem solved for good after disc surgery?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Peul et al. 2007, NEJM
Back to contentsMyth 43
Is the pain guaranteed to be gone after the operation?
In brief: No. An operation fixes the structure that was operated on. If the pain also came from muscles or tendons, it may remain.
The myth
“After the operation, the pain is guaranteed to be gone.”
Many patients expect an operation to end their pain for good. The disappointment is all the greater if the symptoms remain afterwards.
What the research says
Beswick and colleagues (BMJ Open 2012) showed: in the best studies, around 20 % of patients continued to have unfavourable pain after a knee replacement. An update by Cheng and colleagues (BMJ Open 2025) found persistent pain in 12 to 15 % up to two years after knee replacement. [✓ Supported by research]
Our experience
In our experience, muscles, tendons or fasciae that are not treated during the operation are often also involved. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
Before an operation, we establish which structures are involved in your pain. After an operation with persistent pain, we look specifically for further causes.
Related myths
- Myth 42: Does it need surgery – is there no other solution?
- Myth 44: The earlier the operation, the better?
- Myth 46: Is the problem solved for good after disc surgery?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Beswick et al. 2012, BMJ Open · Cheng et al. 2025, BMJ Open
Back to contentsMyth 44
The earlier the operation, the better?
In brief: No. The right timing is crucial – neither too early nor too late.
The myth
“The earlier the operation, the better.”
Some patients want an operation as quickly as possible; others put an operation off for years. Both can be unfavourable.
What the research says
With a herniated disc, early surgery makes you pain-free sooner, but after one year the outcome is the same (Peul 2007). With joint replacement, waiting too long can be harmful: Fortin and colleagues (Arthritis & Rheumatism 2002) showed in 222 patients that those with the worst function before the operation also had worse outcomes two years afterwards. [✓ Supported by research]
Our experience
If a joint replacement is delayed too long, the patient may suddenly be in poorer general health and have to live with the pain. And there are situations in which conservative treatment performs better than surgery. [Clinical experience]
How we approach it
We advise you on whether and when an operation makes sense, and support you with conservative treatment for as long as that is the better approach.
Related myths
- Myth 42: Does it need surgery – is there no other solution?
- Myth 43: Is the pain guaranteed to be gone after the operation?
- Myth 45: Does knee arthroscopy help with wear and tear of the meniscus or cartilage?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Peul et al. 2007, NEJM · Fortin et al. 2002, Arthritis & Rheumatism
Back to contentsMyth 45
Does knee arthroscopy help with wear and tear of the meniscus or cartilage?
In brief: No. Arthroscopy is no longer recommended for wear and tear. It is different with recent injuries, such as a trapped meniscal tear.
The myth
“Arthroscopy helps with wear-related meniscus or cartilage damage.”
Knee arthroscopy for meniscus or cartilage wear was long one of the most common operations in orthopaedics. Many patients are still advised to have it today.
What the research says
Sihvonen and colleagues (NEJM 2013) compared a real operation with a sham operation in 146 patients with a wear-related meniscal tear – after twelve months, there was no difference. Kirkley and colleagues (NEJM 2008) found no additional benefit over physiotherapy and medication for knee osteoarthritis. An international panel of experts makes a strong recommendation in the BMJ (2017) against arthroscopy for almost all wear-related knee symptoms. [✓ Supported by research]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- the knee swells or becomes warm,
- the knee locks or gives way,
- the pain does not ease despite rest.
How we approach it
If you are advised to have knee arthroscopy because of wear and tear, seek a second opinion. We examine where your knee pain comes from and treat the cause conservatively.
Related myths
- Myth 44: The earlier the operation, the better?
- Myth 23: The worse the osteoarthritis on the X-ray, the worse the pain?
- Myth 42: Does it need surgery – is there no other solution?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement
Sources: Sihvonen et al. 2013, NEJM · Kirkley et al. 2008, NEJM · Siemieniuk et al. 2017, BMJ guideline
Back to contentsMyth 46
Is the problem solved for good after disc surgery?
In brief: Not always. Spinal surgery should be carefully considered, because one operation sometimes leads to further operations.
The myth
“After disc surgery, the problem is solved for good.”
Many patients hope that the operation will eliminate all their problems. Sometimes, however, further procedures follow, for example because of scars or problems in the adjacent segment.
What the research says
The study by Peul and colleagues (NEJM 2007) shows that conservative treatment produces equally good outcomes after one year in many patients with a herniated disc. [✓ Supported by research]
Our experience
We are not against operations. If an operation is really necessary, it is the right decision. In our experience, however, this applies to only very few of our patients. What matters is that the right person is operated on. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- you have had cancer in the past,
- the pain began after a serious accident or fall,
- you have taken cortisone for a long time,
- paralysis, numbness in the genital area or problems passing urine occur – this is an emergency.
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 42: Does it need surgery – is there no other solution?
- Myth 43: Is the pain guaranteed to be gone after the operation?
- Myth 2: Herniated disc on MRI – is that the cause of my pain?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Peul et al. 2007, NEJM
Back to contentsOther myths
Myth 47
Is the heel spur to blame for my heel pain?
In brief: The heel spur is not the cause, but a sign of long-standing overload. It is usually the irritated plantar fascia under the foot that hurts.
The myth
“The heel spur on the X-ray is to blame for my heel pain.”
If the X-ray shows a heel spur, the reason for the pain seems to have been found. Many then immediately think of an operation to remove the spur.
What the research says
Heel spurs also occur in people without heel pain: in 11 to 21 % of the young to middle-aged population (Kirkpatrick and colleagues, J Anat 2017). However, people with heel pain have them around five times more often (Drake and colleagues, J Foot Ankle Res 2022) – an indication of long-standing overload. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
The spur develops slowly where the strongest pull acts over the years, usually because of faulty foot alignment or incorrect loading of the foot. The pain often comes from the irritated plantar fascia, a condition known as plantar fasciitis. In our experience, it is often triggered on holiday when walking barefoot on hard ground, such as concrete or tiles by the pool. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- the pain is particularly severe with the first steps in the morning,
- the symptoms persist for longer than a few weeks,
- you can no longer put weight on your foot normally.
How we approach it
We examine the plantar fascia using high-resolution ultrasound and assess foot alignment and loading. The cause is treated, not just the spur.
Related myths
- Myth 48: Does calcium in the shoulder need surgery?
- Myth 30: Is running in the woods or on sand gentler?
- Myth 29: Does running on tarmac harm your joints?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Kirkpatrick et al. 2017, J Anat (heel spur) · Drake et al. 2022, J Foot Ankle Res
Back to contentsMyth 48
Does calcium in the shoulder need surgery?
In brief: Usually not. In isolated calcific tendinitis of the shoulder, surgery is only rarely necessary. Shockwave therapy works very well here.
The myth
“Calcium in the shoulder needs surgery.”
People with calcium in the shoulder are sometimes quickly advised to have surgery. Yet there is a well-studied alternative.
What the research says
Gerdesmeyer and colleagues (JAMA 2003) treated 144 patients with chronic calcific tendinitis of the shoulder with high-energy shockwaves, low-energy shockwaves or a sham treatment. Both forms of shockwave therapy improved function and pain and reduced the size of the calcium deposit. High-energy shockwaves worked significantly better than low-energy shockwaves. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
So the right dose matters. In our experience, many treatments are too short and too weak [Clinical experience]. If other structures are involved, such as the labrum, the biceps tendon or the joint capsule, these must be treated as well. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- the shoulder hurts at night,
- you can no longer raise your arm above your head,
- the shoulder is becoming increasingly stiff.
How we approach it
We use high-resolution ultrasound to check whether there is isolated calcific tendinitis of the shoulder or whether other structures are involved. We then determine the intensity and extent of the shockwave therapy.
Related myths
- Myth 47: Is a heel spur to blame for my heel pain?
- Myth 42: Does it need surgery – is there no other solution?
- Myth 44: The earlier the operation, the better?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Gerdesmeyer et al. 2003, JAMA
Back to contentsMyth 49
Does back pain come from weak abdominal muscles?
In brief: Rarely. Muscular imbalances are only rarely the cause. Abdominal muscle training can help, but it does not replace the search for the actual cause.
The myth
“Back pain comes from weak abdominal muscles.”
“You need to strengthen your core muscles” – many patients with back problems receive this advice. They train diligently, yet the pain remains.
What the research says
The Cochrane review by Saragiotto and colleagues (2016) shows: targeted core and stabilisation training works no better than other forms of exercise. [✓ Supported by research]
Causes and triggers
In our practice, we regularly measure muscle strength and muscular imbalances. Our experience: an imbalance is only rarely the cause of the pain. [Clinical experience]
When to seek medical assessment
Have your symptoms examined by a doctor if
- you have had cancer in the past,
- the pain began after a serious accident or fall,
- you have taken cortisone for a long time,
- paralysis, numbness in the genital area or problems passing urine occur – this is an emergency.
How we approach it
We examine you using our own quadrant method, MRI and high-resolution ultrasound including elastography. This allows us to find out which structures are involved – nerve, muscles, fascia or tendons – and treat each specifically.
Related myths
- Myth 27: Is strength training the best pain therapy?
- Myth 7: Does physiotherapy solve every back problem?
- Myth 36: Does heavy lifting ruin your back?
Key: [✓ Supported by research] a study supports the statement · [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet
Sources: Saragiotto et al. 2016, Cochrane
Back to contentsMyth 50
Pain gone – is the cause gone too?
In brief: Not necessarily. A small ember often remains, a silent inflammation. With the next exertion, it flares up again, like a yo-yo effect.
The myth
“When the pain is gone, the cause is gone too.”
Many patients wait until the pain subsides and then consider the problem resolved. With the next exertion, the symptoms return – often worse than before.
Causes and triggers
The pain often goes away with waiting. But a small ember can remain in the tendon, a silent inflammation [Our hypothesis]. Many of our patients know exactly this pattern [Clinical experience]. That is why we treat the ember, even if the pain is currently gone.
How we approach it
We tell you beforehand how many treatments are needed and check afterwards whether the inflammation has really subsided, for example with ultrasound. This allows you to see for yourself why we continue treatment or stop.
Related myths
- Myth 25: Must I stop doing sport if I am in pain?
- Myth 26: Running less – does that solve the problem?
- Myth 10: Is one method enough if you stick with it long enough?
Key: [Clinical experience] observed regularly in our practice, with no study yet · [Our hypothesis] a physiologically plausible explanation that has yet to be scientifically tested
Back to contents